Website redesign or a new website: which one pays off?

Your website is outdated and you cannot decide whether to have it fixed or order a new one? I describe when a redesign is enough, when a new site is cheaper, and the five questions you can answer yourself before you ask for a quote.

In short: A website redesign pays off when WordPress, the theme and the plugins can be updated and the structure is sound. If the theme is pirated or abandoned, the page builder is no longer developed, or nobody knows the custom system, a new site is the more predictable route. A new business website starts at 2,500 RON with me.

Your site is five or six years old, it falls apart on a phone, and you no longer dare to open anything in the editor. At this point you usually get two quotes: one developer would fix it, the other says only a new site will do. A website redesign is often the better route, though it does not always work out. In this article I describe how I decide when someone comes to me with an old site.

When is a website redesign enough?

A redesign pays off when the foundation is healthy and only the years show on it. These are the signs:

  • WordPress and the plugins can be updated. Perhaps nobody has touched them for two years, but they have a valid version that is still developed today.
  • The theme is alive. Its author releases new versions, and if it is a paid theme, the licence is in your name or can be renewed.
  • The structure is sound. The menu, the pages and most of the copy stay, they only need refreshing.
  • The faults can be named. Slow loading, a mobile view that falls apart, a form that does not work, old photos. Each of these can be fixed on its own.

In this case the work starts with a site assessment. I described how it goes, day by day, in the article about taking over a website.

When is a new site cheaper?

There are a few situations where every fix brings up another fault, and nobody can tell you the cost in advance:

  • A pirated or abandoned theme. It cannot be updated, and there is a good chance it stops working with the next PHP version.
  • A discontinued page builder. If the plugin the pages were built with is no longer developed, the content is stuck inside it.
  • A custom system nobody knows. There is no documentation, and the person who built it cannot be reached.
  • A hacked site that cannot be cleaned. I gave an example of this in the article about three hacked websites.
  • The company has changed in the meantime. The services are different, the audience is different, and hardly any of the old copy stays.

In these cases I say at the end of the assessment that rebuilding is cheaper, and I show where the difference comes from.

Five questions that let you see it yourself

  1. Can you log in to the admin, and is there an update button? If the list of updates is empty because the system no longer even looks for new ones, that is a bad sign.
  2. When did the theme's author last release a version? You see the theme's name under Appearance → Themes, and the date on the author's site. If the last release is more than three years old, plan for a new site.
  3. Can it be used on a phone? Open it and try to get through the menu and the form.
  4. Can you change text on it by yourself? If every change needs a developer, that stays the same after the redesign, unless we rebuild the editing too.
  5. Do enquiries come in through it? If they do, the structure and the copy work, and it would be a waste to throw them away.

If the answer to the first two questions is yes, it almost always ends up as a redesign.

What does each route cost?

A new site has a list price. With me a business website starts at 2,500 RON and an online store at 5,000 RON. The market is similar: in the public price lists of 93 Romanian providers, the entry-level price was 2,250 RON for a business website and 4,972 RON for an online store (median). The details are in the survey of website prices in Romania.

I have no list price for a redesign, because it depends on the state of the site. After the assessment you get a written report and a quote: what I recommend, for how much and in what order. Up to this point you have no obligation, and the report is yours even if you continue with someone else. That way you can put the two quotes side by side.

One cost stays with both routes: updates, backups and monitoring. With me this starts at 250 RON a month, but you can also carry on with it on your own.

What to watch for if a new site is built

The old site has value that Google already knows. Ask the developer for three things, whoever it is:

  • The old addresses should stay, or each one should get a 301 redirect to its new equivalent. Without this the old search results lead to an error page.
  • The copy that performs well should move over. Search Console shows which pages get visitors from search.
  • The domain and the hosting should be in your name. If that is not the case now, the launch of the new site is the best moment to put it right.

How do we decide?

If you do not know which group your site falls into, send me the address and I will tell you what I see on it from the outside. Taking over existing websites starts with the site assessment. If you decide on a new site, the pricing page shows what the basic package includes.

Sárosi Zoltán

Written by

Sárosi Zoltán

Founder, WordPress developer – Eagle Solutions

I have been building websites and online stores from Harghita County since 2011, for small businesses, associations and agency partners. Everything I write here comes from my own projects.

More about me →

Have a question about your own website?

Tell me in a few sentences what you need. I reply within one business day, and the first consultation is free.

Already have a website? Put its address in the message and I'll send you a free 10-point list of what I would improve.

Not sure yet what you need? Work out your price range in two minutes →

Download the 10-point website checklist (PDF) →

← Back to the blog